The Loyalty Test. The Phone Call I Should Have Waited to Make
I made a decision that took less than a second, standing in a parking lot with my phone already in my hand.
At the time, it felt like loyalty. Looking back, I can see it read very differently to the person on the other end of the call, and I would not find out how differently for a few more months.
Some decisions get graded on the spot. Others get graded much later, by people you never see decide, and the outcome shows up long after you have stopped thinking about the moment that caused it.
This is the Hidden Game working exactly as it is built to work. The Hidden Game is everything happening beneath the official org chart: loyalty tests, succession signals, risk calculations, and decisions made before anyone says them out loud. No scorecard, no announcement. Just the outcome, whenever it happens to arrive.
The One-on-One
My team had just finished a large project, and we were in the early, quiet stage of discussing the next one. No emergencies, nothing on the horizon. Executives from other locations visited from time to time, so when I was told my boss's boss wanted to fly in and thank the team in person, it did not register as unusual.
He met with the team, then asked for a one-on-one with me. That was not unusual either. We had a good working relationship.
The conversation felt routine, until it did not.
“What would you do,” he asked, “if your boss was no longer here?”
I told him my boss was doing outstanding work, that he had the respect of the entire team, and that losing him would be a devastating shock. I meant every word of it.
He nodded. We wrapped up the meeting. He left for the airport, and I started heading home.
Before I reached my car, I had my phone out. I called my boss and told him everything: the meeting, the question, my answer, all of it. I considered him a friend. We had worked together for years. I thought he was in danger and that he needed to know.
It was a purely emotional decision. Had I stopped to think about it, even for a moment, I might have done something different. I did not stop. I acted on impulse.
Two Mistakes, Not One
Looking back, I can see I made two mistakes at the same time, and I recognized neither of them in the moment.
The first is the more obvious one now. A senior executive does not fly into your location, sit down with you for a one-on-one, and ask about replacing your boss as a casual hypothetical. That conversation was about how I would position myself if the power dynamics shifted. My defense of my boss was genuine, but it placed me in exactly the wrong spot. I had demonstrated loyalty to a person instead of loyalty to the organization. I did not realize the center of power had already moved.
The second mistake is the one I think about more, because it is far less obvious.
By calling my boss, I thought I was protecting a friend. What I did not think through was how that call would look from his side. He now knew that corporate had chosen me, specifically, and not anyone else on the team, to have that conversation. I have no way to know for certain, but I suspect that call cost me his trust. Not because of anything I said during the call, but because the conversation had happened at all, and because my being chosen for it may have implied something ominous.
Our relationship was never quite the same after that.
A Few Months Later
My boss called. Our entire team was being laid off. Officially, it was presented as a location shutdown, and to be fair, that much was true. A few other locations closed around the same time.
He flew in to deliver the news in person. He told me he had tried to push back, and that the answer he got was simple: if you do not want to do this, we will find somebody else who will.
A few people on the team were offered positions in other locations. I was not one of them.
Would a different decision have changed that outcome? I do not know. There is no way for me to know, and I have made my peace with not knowing. The point is not that the phone call caused the layoff. The point is that I failed to recognize the political meaning of the moment before I acted.
What I Would Tell My Younger Self
I made my moves without understanding the full game board. Organizations do not grade on intent. They grade on actions.
The lesson here is not that you should be less loyal, or that you should stop caring about the people you work with. It is that you need to understand which game is actually being played before you act, especially when your instincts are telling you to do the right thing.
Would my boss have pushed harder to keep the location open if I had acted differently? Would his boss have reached a different conclusion if I had shown organizational loyalty instead of personal loyalty? Possibly. It is also entirely possible the result would have been exactly the same, for completely different reasons. There is no parallel universe to check against.
What I do know is this: I made a mistake by acting on impulse, and that is the mistake I could have avoided. Hindsight arrives for free and too late. Pattern recognition is the version you can actually build. When someone powerful asks a question that feels hypothetical, pause before treating it as ordinary information.
This is the written version of Episode 4 of The Hidden Game, “An Offer. Refused. Then I Made It Worse.” Real stories from thirty years inside large software enterprises, and what they reveal about how these places actually work. And if you are navigating something at work that does not quite add up, there is a free discovery call. A real conversation, not a pitch.
Comments